First off – what did they sing from the judges to Jimmy’s to their own picks:

Haley Reinhart

Judges Choice – You Oughta Know by Alanis Morrisette

Jimmy’s Choice – Rhiannon by Fleetwood Mac

Haley’s Choice – What Is and What Should Never Be by Led Zeppelin

Scotty McCreery

Judges Choice – She Believes In Me by Kenny Rogers

Jimmie’s Choice – Are you going to kiss me or not by Thompson Square

Scotty’s Choice – Amaze by Lonestar

Lauren Alaina

Judges Choice – I Hope You Dance by LeeAnn Womack

Jimmy’s Choice – If I die young by Perry

Lauren’s Choice – Wild One by Faith Hill

Quick hits:

Ranking them is pretty easy: Scotty, Haley, Lauren…

Scotty is playing it safe and why shouldn’t he?

Lauren is showing her youth… maybe she should have waited a couple of years to do this…

As the contestants get a little better, the judges get a lot worse … I’m so tired of hearing the cliches…

None of the song choices knocked my socks off…

Here’s a tip: All three of these finalists will sound much, much better in person on the Idol Summer Tour…